Eric Sepanek
SBC Founder
Eric Sepanek is the founder of Scottsdale Bullion & Coin, established in 2011. With extensive experience in the precious metals industry, he is dedicated to educating Americans on the wealth preservation power of gold and silver.
Add SBC on Google as a preferred source to see more market related news like this when you search.
For decades, Morgan Silver Dollars and American Silver Eagles have earned a special place in coin collectors’ and precious metals investors’ portfolios, albeit for different reasons.
The Morgan Silver Dollar is a piece of classic US coinage steeped in history, attracting numismatists, collectors, and vintage silver enthusiasts. Conversely, the relatively younger American Silver Eagle is the official silver bullion coin of the United States, making it a staple in silver investment strategies and portfolio diversification.
Given their distinct histories, silver content, and investment merits, investors and collectors need to understand each coin’s unique qualities before deciding which silver coin fits their goals.
Key Differences Between the Morgan Dollar and American Silver Eagle
While both coins are popular among collectors and investors, the Morgan Silver Dollar and American Silver Eagle differ in purity, origin, mintage, and investment appeal. The table below highlights the most important distinctions between these two iconic US silver coins.
| Morgan Dollar | Silver Eagle | |
|---|---|---|
| Purity | 90.0% silver (1878–1904, 1921) 99.9% silver (2021–present) | 99.9% silver |
| Sizes | 1 oz | 1 oz |
| Mint Years | 1878–1904, 1921, 2021–Present | 1986–present (bullion) 1986–2008, 2010–present (proof) 2006–2008, 2011–present (uncirculated) |
| Mintage Numbers | 658,806,242 (as of 2024) | 690,933,726 (as of 2024) |
| Mint Locations (Mint Mark) | Carson City (CC) Denver (D) New Orleans (O) Philadelphia (None) San Francisco (S) | Philadelphia (none) San Francisco (S) West Point (W) |
| Versions | Circulated, Uncirculated, & Proof | Bullion, Proof, & Uncirculated |
| IRA Eligibility | No (1878–1904, 1921) Yes (2021–present) | Yes |
Origins of Morgan Dollars and Silver Eagles
Morgan Silver Dollar History
The launch of the Morgan Silver Dollar coincides with a momentous time in American history. The design pays homage to the westward expansion of the US and the booming Industrial Revolution.
Notably, the Morgan Silver dollar was the first silver coin produced after the Coinage Act of 1873, legislation that temporarily demonetized silver to support the gold standard. Initially minted between 1879 and 1904, Morgan Silver Dollars are widely considered a hallmark of classic American coins.
American Silver Eagle History
Towards the end of the 20th century, the US government hoarded a considerable amount of silver. Reserves got so bloated that many people worried they would impact silver volatility. In response, the government decided to issue silver coins made from the National Defense Stockpile. The resulting American Silver Eagle quickly became the official bullion coin of the US and one of the most in-demand coins.
Silver Purity: How Morgan Dollars and Silver Eagles Compare
Purity refers to the percentage of a coin composed of precious metals. Both Morgan Silver Dollars and American Silver Eagles feature high fineness ratings, making them popular precious metals assets. However, purity ratings vary across different mint dates.
Morgan Dollars minted from 1878 to 1904 and 1921 have a 90% silver purity. This lined up with standard circulating coins at the time. Re-issued versions produced since 2021 feature .999 fineness.
On the other hand, American Silver Eagles have always boasted 99.9% silver. This bullion coin achieved higher precious metals content due to its later release, after minting technology had advanced considerably.
Coin Weight and Composition Differences
Although both coins are marketed as one-ounce silver pieces, their actual weight and silver content differ in a way that’s worth understanding before comparing value or investment potential. Both Morgan Silver Dollars and American Silver Eagles are issued in only one size: 1 troy ounce. While Morgan Dollars are often referred to as 1-ounce coins by investors, they actually weigh slightly less. Specifically, Morgan Dollars weigh 0.859 troy ounces, with 0.7734 troy ounces of pure silver.
Originally, Morgan Dollars were minted to match their $1 face value, as the market price of silver at the time was roughly equivalent to the coin’s denomination. Alternatively, American Silver Eagles have always been minted for investment purposes. All versions have one troy ounce of silver, resulting in a weight of 31.103 grams.
Designs (Obverse & Reverse)
Morgan Silver Dollar Appearance
A bust of a regal and strong Lady Liberty is adorned with a crown and liberty cap. The word LIBERTY is written on the diadem. The US motto E. PLURIBUS UNUM arches over the top of the image with the mint date at the bottom.
13 stars, representing the original colonies, surround the obverse side. An Eagle with its wings spread graces the reverse side of the Morgan Dollar. An olive branch and a fasces are clenched in its talons. THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA rests above, and the coin’s mint date sits below.
American Silver Eagle Appearance
The American Silver Eagle features a hopeful image of Lady Liberty striding confidently toward the sunrise, draped in the American flag. She’s holding an olive branch in her left hand while her right is extended towards the horizon.
The mint date and IN GOD WE TRUST is written on the bottom. The reverse features the eponymous eagle in mid-flight, clutching arrows and an olive branch in its talons. Thirteen stars hover over the eagle, representing the original colonies with the inscription THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and the coin’s face value below.
Because collectible coins like the Morgan Dollar can attract counterfeiters, it’s worth knowing how to tell if a coin is a replica before adding one to your collection.
Market Value & Auction History
Morgan Silver Dollar Value
Morgan Dollars tend to earn higher evaluations than their American Eagle counterparts due to their numismatic appeal. Characteristics such as scarcity, historical significance, and age result in greater worth.
While the most valuable Morgan Dollar sits at $1.2 million, most versions don’t reach this impressive limit. The least valuable Morgan Dollars hover around $45, and higher-value versions have sold for a few thousand or tens of thousands of dollars, according to auction data from the Numismatic Guaranty Company (NGC).
American Silver Eagle Value
The value of most American Silver Eagles is primarily derived from their precious metal content. As a result, the worth of these coins closely follows the silver spot price. For instance, when the price of silver reaches $35 per ounce, a 1-oz Silver Eagle would hold a similar value.
Due to their status as bullion coins with extremely high mintage numbers, Silver Eagles generally don’t gain additional value from numismatic factors, unlike Morgan Dollars, which are often evaluated based on their rarity and collectible features. Consequently, Silver Eagles tend to have lower market valuations.
Unlock Silver Investor Trade Secrets in our Investor Report.
Get Your Free ReportLifetime Mintage Numbers (Up to 2024)
Morgan Silver Dollar
The Morgan Silver Dollar enjoyed early but not sustained production, with initial minting only lasting between 1878 and 1904. There was a brief resurgence of this iconic coin in 1921, but it was replaced by the Peace Dollar the following year.
In 2021, the US Mint resurrected the Morgan Dollar for a centennial celebration and has continued minting limited collectible versions since then. Despite the coin’s relatively short production span, a total of 658,806,242 Morgan Silver Dollars have been minted to date.
American Silver Eagle
The US Mint has minted the American Silver Eagle every year since its initial launch in 1986, owing to the coin’s popularity. In total, 690,933,726 Silver Eagles have been produced.
Circulated, Proof, and Uncirculated Versions
Morgan Silver Dollar
Originally minted for everyday use, the majority of Morgan Silver Dollars were circulated as standard currency. Only 880 proof coins were produced during the initial minting period between 1878 and 1904, making them extremely rare. Since the revival of the Morgan Dollar in 2021, the US Mint has issued uncirculated and proof coins.
American Silver Eagle
The majority of Silver Eagles are standard bullion coins. However, a significant number of proof and uncirculated versions exist. To be precise, there are 657,646,982 bullion, 28,499,151 proof, and 4,787,593 uncirculated Silver Eagles.
Are Morgan Dollars and Silver Eagles IRA eligible?
Contrary to conventional wisdom, investors are allowed to hold physical precious metals in their retirement portfolios. Through a silver IRA, you can use tax-advantaged dollars to purchase silver products.
However, coins must meet certain eligibility standards, such as 99.9% silver purity. This means Silver Eagles are IRA-eligible while older Morgan Dollars aren’t. Modern versions produced since 2021 meet this requirement, though.
Curious how precious metals fit alongside stocks and bonds? See how a silver IRA compares to the traditional 60/40 portfolio model to round out your retirement strategy.
Should I invest in Morgan Dollars or Silver Eagles?
Well, it all depends on your unique investment goals. Both silver coins offer specific advantages and considerations. If you’re also weighing silver against other metals, our breakdown of platinum vs. silver as an investment can help you decide where silver fits into a broader precious metals strategy. Working with a precious metals advisor can help determine which of these coins can help you reach your financial objectives. The experienced team at Scottsdale Bullion & Coin would be happy to answer all your questions. Contact us today by calling toll-free at 1-888-812-9892 or using our live chat function.